Circumcision Debate: Yes or No?

(Ivanhoe Newswire) -- One-point-two million American infants are circumcised. Although it's one of the most common procedures … it's also one of the most controversial -- raising conflicting notions about personal hygiene, sexually transmitted diseases, masculinity, sexuality and religion. Now, many parents are rethinking their decisions as the debate surrounding the benefits of the procedure heat up.

A baby boy comes into the world and parents have to decide if he will undergo surgery within the first few hours of his life.

"I think it's a hot topic because there are pros and cons and it's not clear which side to hang your hat on," Elizabeth Dickey, M.D., pediatrician at Baylor Grapevine Hospital in

Grapevine, Texas, told Ivanhoe.

Circumcision has been a tradition in some faiths since biblical times. Until recently, as many as 89 percent of newborn boys born in the United States were circumcised, most for hygienic reasons.

But now, moms like Noemi Siller are choosing to skip the surgery.

"I have seen them do it before, they strap them down, I think it would hurt me more than him," Siller said.

Circumcision is believed to reduce the number of urinary tract infections in boys, lower the risk of penile cancer later in life and lower the risk of syphilis and HIV.

"It looks like there is a slightly greater chance of Sexually transmitted diseases with uncircumcised males," Dr. Dickey said.

But the American academy of pediatrics says while there may be benefits, the risks should also be weighed.

"There's an increase risk of bleeding and infection and trauma. You are doing a medically unnecessary procedure; you are electing to do it," Dr. Dickey said.

It's so controversial; some doctors refuse to do it, saying it's barbaric. One group is even calling for an end to all non-religious circumcisions.

"You are going to have to look at the risk factors and where is your comfort zone," Dr. Dickey said. 

Dr. Dickey emphasized the bottom line is there is no right or wrong answer. If you choose not to have your son circumcised, make sure you explain it to your doctor before you go in for delivery.

If you would like more information, please contact:

Marsha Hitchcock

News Director, Ivanhoe Broadcast News

mhitchcock@Ivanhoe.com